
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families and groups who want on-site activities, outdoor grounds, and a pet-friendly stay.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a family- and dog-friendly lodge in Sister Bay with on-site activities, a heated indoor pool, and roomy grounds — a good pick for families and groups who want activities without leaving the property. Waterbury Inn is an aparthotel in Ephraim with condo-style units (kitchens, private patios/balconies) and both indoor and seasonal outdoor pools — a fit for travelers who want apartment conveniences near Lake Michigan.
Updated · about 5 km apart

Best for families and groups who want on-site activities, outdoor grounds, and a pet-friendly stay.

Best for travelers who want apartment-style rooms with kitchens and easy walking access to Ephraim and the lake.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: choose Open Hearth if you want family-focused facilities (playground, disc golf, fire pit), a year-round heated indoor pool with an adjacent whirlpool, a fitness center and sauna, and a dedicated dog wing so pets can join the stay.
When Waterbury Inn wins: pick Waterbury Inn when you prefer condo-style accommodations (kitchens, private balconies/patios), on-site laundry and computer station, and quick walking access to Eagle Harbor/Lake Michigan and small Ephraim galleries.
Bottom line: both are practical, family-friendly Door County options but they serve different trip styles — Open Hearth centers on on-site recreation and grounds, Waterbury focuses on self-catering units and a location close to the waterfront and village attractions.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | Waterbury Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lodge on 6.4 acres focused on family activities and group stays | Aparthotel with individually decorated condo-style units |
| Location (town) | Sister Bay (south end of town, on Hwy 42) | Ephraim, within a short walk of Lake Michigan/Eagle Harbor |
| Size (rooms) | 55 guest rooms | 46 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Audience / ages | All ages; family- and kid-friendly | All ages; not adults-only |
| Pools & hot tubs | Year-round heated indoor pool + adjacent whirlpool (8:00 AM–10:00 PM) | Indoor pool, 1 hot tub, and a seasonal outdoor pool |
| Rooms — layout & kitchen | Standard hotel rooms and suites; refrigerators and microwaves in rooms; select suites/fireplaces/whirlpools | Rooms include full-sized refrigerators/freezers and stovetops; private balconies/patios in many units |
| Dining & food service | Free daily continental breakfast; outdoor BBQ grills and fire pit; no full-service restaurant | Coffee/tea in common areas; no full-service restaurant listed |
| Wellness & fitness | Fitness center and infrared sauna on site; fitness/sauna hours published | No dedicated spa listed; pools and hot tub available |
| Pet policy | Dog-friendly wing (14 rooms), $15 per dog per night, up to 2 dogs; cats not allowed | Not published in supplier listing whether pets allowed |
| Nearby highlights | Close to Sister Bay beach, Waterfront Park, shops and restaurants in Sister Bay | Within walking distance of Lake Michigan/Eagle Harbor and Francis Hardy Gallery |
Open Hearth Lodge sits on the south end of Sister Bay on Highway 42 with direct access to trails and a short drive to local beaches and attractions.
Choose Open Hearth for easy access to Sister Bay sights and driving day trips around the peninsula.
Waterbury Inn is in Ephraim within easy walking distance of Lake Michigan and village galleries.
Pick Waterbury Inn if you want village walking access to the waterfront and Ephraim’s small attractions.
Open Hearth offers hotel-style rooms, suites, and specialty rooms (King Whirlpool, fireplaces), plus a 14-room dog wing.
Go to Open Hearth for traditional hotel rooms with family- and pet-focused options.
Waterbury Inn’s units are apartment-style with kitchens, private balconies/patios, and pillowtop beds.
Waterbury Inn suits guests who want to self-cater or stay longer with kitchen facilities.
Open Hearth does not operate a full-service restaurant; food options are centered on complimentary breakfast and guest cookouts.
If on-site restaurant service matters, plan to eat in town — Open Hearth focuses on casual self-catering and breakfast.
Waterbury Inn lists limited common-area beverage service and no full-service restaurant in the supplier listing.
Waterbury is set up for self-catering or village dining rather than on-site restaurant meals.
Open Hearth emphasizes its 6.4 acres of outdoor space and an expansive indoor pool plus whirlpool.
Families who want outdoor play space and an active pool area will prefer Open Hearth.
Waterbury Inn provides both indoor and seasonal outdoor pools plus a hot tub for guest recreation.
Waterbury is a good choice if you want pool options combined with apartment-style rooms near the village.
Open Hearth has on-site fitness and an infrared sauna plus casual evening options on the grounds.
Choose Open Hearth if you want an on-site fitness/sauna and evening outdoor social spaces.
Waterbury Inn offers pools and a hot tub but does not list a fitness center or spa treatments in the supplier details.
Waterbury is more focused on relaxed stays and self-service conveniences than wellness facilities.

Open Hearth — playground, large grounds, indoor pool made for kids, game room and outdoor activities on 6.4 acres.

Waterbury Inn — rooms with full-sized refrigerators, stovetops, and private balconies make it easy to self-cater.

Open Hearth — a 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area and dog wash are available (pet fee applies).

Waterbury Inn — within a short walk of Lake Michigan/Eagle Harbor and village galleries in Ephraim.
Open Hearth Lodge — it has a playground, large grounds, on-site activities, and a wide, kid-friendly indoor pool.
Waterbury Inn rooms include kitchens with full-sized refrigerators/freezers and stovetops; Open Hearth rooms have refrigerators and microwaves, but not full kitchens.
Open Hearth allows dogs only in its 14-room dog-friendly wing (reserve in advance; fee and rules apply). Waterbury Inn’s supplier listing does not specify pet policy.
No full-service restaurant is listed for either property. Open Hearth offers a free continental breakfast, BBQ grills, and vending; Waterbury lists coffee/tea in common areas and in-room kitchens for self-catering.
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·