
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families and guests traveling with dogs who want space, on-site play and outdoor gathering areas.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a family- and dog-friendly Door County lodge on about 6.4 acres with an indoor pool, playground, and grounds for cookouts and trails. AmericInn by Wyndham Menominee is a 3-star chain hotel on the Menominee waterfront with dependable, road-trip–friendly amenities and a complimentary full breakfast — read on if you’re choosing between a characterful Door County stay and straightforward chain lodging near Lake Michigan.
Updated

Best for families and guests traveling with dogs who want space, on-site play and outdoor gathering areas.

Best for travelers who want predictable, chain-hotel comforts, an indoor pool/hot tub, and a quick stop near Menominee’s shoreline.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: choose Open Hearth Lodge if you want Door County character, larger grounds (6.4 acres) for outdoor activities, a dog-friendly wing and features aimed at families (playground, disc golf, fire pit, BBQ grills).
When AmericInn wins: pick AmericInn if you prefer a Wyndham/chain experience with a full complimentary breakfast, a clear set of accessible features, and a very short walk to Lake Michigan from the hotel’s location in Menominee.
Bottom line: Open Hearth Lodge is the choice for a more distinctive local feel and outdoor space (and for guests with dogs); AmericInn is the more straightforward, accessible chain option for a no-surprises waterfront stay and easy road-trip logistics.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | AmericInn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Small-lodge, family-focused with Door County character and outdoor grounds | Chain hotel with dependable, practical guest services |
| Location | South end of Sister Bay, close to Sister Bay Beach and local attractions | Menominee waterfront; Lake Michigan is about 0.1 mi away |
| Size (rooms) | 55 guest rooms | 62 guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages; family facilities and playground | All ages; not adults-only |
| Pools & hot tubs | Year-round heated indoor pool and adjacent jacuzzi whirlpool (open 8:00 AM–10:00 PM) | Indoor pool and hot tub (supplier listing) |
| Restaurants & bars | No full-service restaurant on site — free continental breakfast, BBQ grills, fire pit, vending | Free full breakfast; vending and lobby services; no on-site signature restaurant named |
| Wellness / spa | Infrared sauna and fitness center; whirlpool (no dedicated treatment spa on site) | Listing includes a wheelchair-accessible spa and fitness facilities |
| Pet policy / pet facilities | Dedicated 14-room dog-friendly wing, dog exercise area, dog wash; $15 per dog/night | Pets allowed in specific rooms with a pet fee (USD 30 per pet noted in supplier listing) |
| Free breakfast | Free daily continental breakfast with conveyor pancake maker | Free full breakfast (weekday and weekend hours noted in listing) |
| Grounds & outdoor space | 6.4 acres with patio, fire pit, gas grills, playground, disc golf, trails | Picnic area, firepit, and lakeside proximity but not large private grounds |
Open Hearth Lodge sits on the south end of Sister Bay, near beaches, local galleries, and Door County attractions.
Choose Open Hearth if you want to be in the Sister Bay/peninsula setting with easy access to Door County day trips.
AmericInn is in Menominee with a short walk to the Lake Michigan shoreline and local points of interest.
Pick AmericInn for a straightforward waterfront location and short drives to Menominee sights.
Open Hearth Lodge offers 55 rooms and suites with in-room fridges, microwaves, and some rooms featuring fireplaces or whirlpool tubs.
Open Hearth works well for families and groups who want suite options and pet-friendly rooms on-site.
AmericInn lists 62 guestrooms with a broad set of standard room types and water-view options.
AmericInn is strong if you want predictable chain-room choices and accessibility options.
Open Hearth does not operate a full-service on-site restaurant; breakfast and DIY options are the norm.
Expect casual, self-service dining and to rely on nearby Sister Bay restaurants for full meals.
AmericInn provides a complimentary full breakfast and basic on-site food services.
AmericInn suits travelers who want a sturdy morning meal included and local dining for other meals.
Open Hearth’s signature amenity is its wide, year-round heated indoor pool and adjacent jacuzzi whirlpool.
Families who want a lively indoor pool and a whirlpool will favor Open Hearth.
AmericInn lists an indoor pool and a hot tub among its recreational amenities.
AmericInn is a solid option for travelers who want an indoor pool and accessible pool features in a chain-hotel setting.
Open Hearth has an on-site fitness center and an infrared sauna, plus low-key evening options on the grounds.
Choose Open Hearth if you want basic on-site wellness like a sauna and a relaxed night outdoors.
AmericInn includes fitness facilities and lists a wheelchair-accessible spa in its supplier amenities.
AmericInn fits visitors who want fitness access and basic spa/pool facilities with the consistency of a chain.

Open Hearth Lodge — playground, game room options, large pool, and grounds geared to family activities.

Open Hearth Lodge — a dedicated 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area and dog wash, with a lower per-dog fee ($15/night).

AmericInn — explicit accessible-room inventory, wheelchair-accessible features, and a clear chain-hotel operations model.

AmericInn — listed about 0.1 mi from Lake Michigan and close to Menominee attractions.
Open Hearth Lodge is set up specifically for dogs with a 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area and dog wash; AmericInn accepts pets in specified rooms (supplier listing) but follows chain pet policies and higher per-pet fees in the listing.
Neither is all-inclusive; both offer complimentary breakfast (Open Hearth: continental with a conveyor pancake maker; AmericInn: full breakfast per the listing), and other meals are from nearby restaurants or self-catered.
AmericInn’s supplier listing calls out numerous accessibility features (accessible rooms, pool access, accessible parking); AmericInn is likely the safer pick if accessibility is a primary concern.
Open Hearth has an infrared sauna and a whirlpool but no dedicated treatment spa; AmericInn’s supplier listing includes a wheelchair-accessible spa feature, though a named treatment spa is not described.
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·