
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families, groups, and travelers bringing dogs who want easy access to trails, on-site kid-friendly amenities, and casual cookout options.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a casual, family- and dog-friendly lodge with trails, BBQ grills, and a year-round indoor pool; good for families and travelers with dogs who want relaxed, outdoor-oriented lodging. Birchwood Lodge is a three-star, resort-style property in Sister Bay known for spacious suites and multiple pool/fitness amenities; read this if you prefer larger rooms and on-site resort facilities.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for families, groups, and travelers bringing dogs who want easy access to trails, on-site kid-friendly amenities, and casual cookout options.

Best for guests who want larger suites, multiple pool options, and a fuller set of resort-style wellness and recreation facilities.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: Choose Open Hearth if you need a genuinely family- and dog-friendly place with direct trail access, a large indoor pool open year-round, BBQ grills and a fire pit, and a property layout that suits groups and active families.
When Birchwood Lodge wins: Pick Birchwood if you want more polished resort amenities — indoor and outdoor pools, a dedicated fitness/fitness center and spa features, and larger suite-style accommodations.
Bottom line: If your trip centers on family activities, bringing a dog, or a relaxed, outdoorsy stay, Open Hearth is the practical choice. If you want resort-style facilities and roomy suites without sacrificing basic accessibility and wellness offerings, Birchwood fits better.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | Birchwood Lodge |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casual, family- and dog-focused lodge with outdoor grounds | Polished, resort-style property with suite focus |
| Location in Sister Bay | South end of Sister Bay on Highway 42 (2669 S Bay Shore Dr) | 10571 Wisconsin 57, Sister Bay (WI) 54234 |
| Size (rooms) | 55 guest rooms | Not published |
| Who it's for | Families, groups, dog owners | Guests wanting larger suites and resort-style amenities |
| Pools | Year-round heated indoor pool + adjacent whirlpool (8:00 AM–10:00 PM) | Indoor and outdoor swimming pools listed |
| Restaurants & bars | No full-service on-site restaurant; free continental breakfast, BBQ grills, lobby vending | Not published |
| Spa & wellness | Fitness center and infrared sauna; no dedicated treatment spa on site | Spa, fitness center, hot tub, sauna listed |
| Family / kids | Playground, game room, family rooms, kid-friendly pool hours | Family room listed among amenities |
| Accessibility & safety | Free parking, inside entries, accessible grounds; policies vary by room | Wheelchair accessible, elevator, facilities for disabled guests, many safety/health measures listed |
| Pet policy | Dedicated 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area, dog wash; fees apply | Not published |
Open Hearth sits on roughly 6.4 acres at the south end of Sister Bay on Highway 42, with easy access to local beaches, trails, and nearby restaurants.
Open Hearth is convenient for outdoor activities and quick access to Sister Bay's south-end attractions.
Birchwood Lodge is located on Wisconsin 57 in Sister Bay; the supplier listing places it within easy reach of town highlights.
Birchwood is well-situated for visiting Sister Bay’s downtown and waterfront points of interest.
Open Hearth offers a range of 55 rooms and suites (king, two-queen, whirlpool and select fireplaces), including a 14-room dog wing.
Rooms are practical, varied, and set up for families and guests traveling with dogs.
Birchwood highlights spacious suites on its supplier listing (room types include Honeymoon Studio and Luxury Condo).
Birchwood leans toward suite-style and larger rooms; check the supplier for exact room sizes and bedding layouts.
Open Hearth does not operate a full-service restaurant but includes a free morning continental breakfast and casual cookout options.
Expect simple, self-service breakfast and casual on-site cookout options; nearby Sister Bay restaurants provide sit-down dining.
Birchwood’s supplier listing includes common resort amenities but does not publish a named on-site restaurant.
Birchwood offers resort dining support items but the supplier listing does not publish a full-service restaurant name or breakfast details.
Open Hearth’s signature amenity is its wide year-round heated indoor pool with an adjacent jacuzzi-style whirlpool.
If an indoor, family-friendly pool is important, Open Hearth is set up for active kids and casual swimmers year-round.
Birchwood’s listing includes both indoor and outdoor swimming pool facilities and multiple recreation options.
Birchwood provides multiple pool options; contact the property for current pool hours and rules.
Open Hearth has a fitness center and an infrared sauna but no full-service spa for treatments.
Wellness at Open Hearth is functional (gym, sauna, whirlpool) rather than spa-focused; evenings are low-key and family-oriented.
Birchwood lists a fitness center, spa, hot tub, and sauna among its supplier amenities.
Birchwood leans more toward full-service resort wellness and wider recreational options; confirm spa services directly with the property.

Open Hearth — playground, game room, family rooms, and a kid-friendly indoor pool make it easy for families to stay on-site and be entertained.

Birchwood — supplier listing highlights spacious suites and condo-style units like Luxury Condo and Honeymoon Studio.

Open Hearth — a dedicated 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area, and dog wash simplify travel with dogs.

Birchwood — lists indoor & outdoor pools, spa, hot tub, sauna, and a fitness center in its supplier amenities.
Open Hearth is set up for dogs with a 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area, and dog wash; Birchwood’s supplier listing does not publish a pet program.
No — Open Hearth includes a free continental breakfast but is not all-inclusive. Birchwood’s supplier listing does not publish an all-inclusive meal plan.
Birchwood lists a spa, hot tub, sauna and fitness center; Open Hearth has a fitness center and infrared sauna but no dedicated treatment spa on site.
Yes. Open Hearth is explicitly family- and dog-friendly; Birchwood lists a family room among amenities and is not shown as adults-only.
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·