
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families and travelers with dogs who want roomy grounds, an indoor heated pool open year-round, and outdoor cookout space.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a family- and dog-friendly lodge on 6.4 acres at the south end of Sister Bay; read this if you want large grounds, family amenities, and pet travel. Newport Resort is a classic Egg Harbor resort with suites and on-site recreation; read this if you want a central Egg Harbor base with pools, meeting space, and in-room kitchens.
Updated

Best for families and travelers with dogs who want roomy grounds, an indoor heated pool open year-round, and outdoor cookout space.

Best for guests who want Egg Harbor–centered suites with kitchen facilities, meeting space, and resort-style indoor/outdoor pools.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: choose Open Hearth Lodge if you’re traveling with kids or dogs, want easy access to trails and Sister Bay beaches, and prefer an on-site playground, large outdoor grounds, BBQ grills, and a year-round heated indoor pool with adjacent whirlpool.
When Newport Resort wins: choose Newport Resort if you want to stay in Egg Harbor for short walking trips to Main Street, need suite-style rooms with full kitchens, or want on-site resort recreation (indoor pool, outdoor seasonal pool, hot tub, sauna) and meeting/conference space.
Bottom line: Open Hearth Lodge is the better pick for family-and-pet-centered stays and outdoor grounds; Newport Resort is a practical, recreation-focused choice in Egg Harbor with suites and meeting facilities. Pick based on whether you want a Sister Bay lodge experience or a central Egg Harbor resort base.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | Newport Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casual, family-focused lodge on multi-acre grounds | Midscale resort with a focus on suites and on-site recreation |
| Location | South end of Sister Bay (Hwy 42) with direct trail access and nearby Sister Bay Beach | In Egg Harbor (7888 Church St), within short drives of Main Street shops and Egg Harbor Beach |
| Size (rooms) | 55 guest rooms per property materials | 59 air-conditioned rooms |
| Ages allowed | All ages (family-focused) | |
| Pools | Year-round heated indoor pool + adjoining jacuzzi whirlpool | Indoor pool, outdoor seasonal pool (seasonal dates published), hot tub and sauna |
| Restaurants & bars | No full-service on-site restaurant; free daily continental breakfast, BBQ grills, fire pit, vending | No specific signature restaurant listed in supplier facts; food/drink amenities and a bar are not published beyond on-site conveniences |
| Spa / wellness | Fitness center and an infrared sauna; no published full-service treatment spa | Fitness facilities, sauna, hot tub; full-service spa not published |
| Known for | Dog-friendly wing, family programming, large grounds and outdoor activities | Egg Harbor suites with kitchens, conference space, and on-site recreation |
| Meeting & event space | Accommodation for groups and weddings across indoor/outdoor spaces; no published banquet capacities | Conference space (550 sq ft) and 2 meeting rooms |
| Parking & access | Free self-parking plus motor-coach/bus parking | |
Open Hearth Lodge sits on roughly 6.4 acres at the south end of Sister Bay on Highway 42.
Choose Open Hearth if you want big outdoor grounds near Sister Bay attractions and trail access.
Newport Resort is located in Egg Harbor at 7888 Church St, within easy reach of Main Street and harbor attractions.
Choose Newport when you want a central Egg Harbor base with short drives to beaches and shops.
Open Hearth Lodge offers 55 rooms including suites, King Whirlpool rooms, and a 14-room dog-friendly wing.
Pick Open Hearth for family-friendly room options and explicit pet rooms.
Newport Resort’s rooms include Standard and Premier layouts in 1‑ and 2‑bedroom formats.
Choose Newport if you want suite-style rooms with full kitchens for self-catering.
Open Hearth doesn’t run a full-service restaurant but does include a daily continental breakfast and outdoor cookout options.
Open Hearth suits guests comfortable with self-catering and nearby restaurants rather than an on-site restaurant.
Newport’s supplier listing highlights in-room kitchens and on-site conveniences but does not publish a named signature restaurant.
Newport is practical for guests who prefer suite kitchens or to eat out in Egg Harbor; a named signature restaurant is not published in the supplier listing.
Open Hearth promotes a wide, year-round heated indoor pool and an adjacent jacuzzi whirlpool.
If a year-round indoor swimming area and family pool fun are priorities, Open Hearth is a strong fit.
Newport Resort lists both an indoor pool and an outdoor seasonal pool, plus a hot tub and sauna.
Newport works well if you want a mix of indoor and outdoor seasonal pool options plus extra on-site recreation.
Open Hearth features a fitness center and an infrared sauna; nightlife is low-key around the fire pit.
Choose Open Hearth for straightforward wellness facilities and relaxed, family-friendly evenings.
Newport Resort lists fitness facilities, a sauna, and on-site entertainment like an arcade/game room.
Newport offers basic wellness amenities and casual on-site entertainment; nightlife happens principally in town.

Playground, large grounds, family pool hours, and kid-friendly breakfast make Open Hearth the easier family pick.

Open Hearth’s dedicated 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area and dog wash are set up for pet travel.

Newport’s 1- and 2-bedroom room types with full kitchens suit guests who want to cook in-room.

Newport places you close to Egg Harbor’s Main Street, harbor, and nearby beaches and shops.
Open Hearth Lodge — it has a dedicated 14-room dog-friendly wing, a dog exercise area, and a dog wash (advance reservation and pet fee required).
Open Hearth Lodge has a year-round heated indoor pool; Newport has an indoor pool plus an outdoor seasonal pool (seasonal dates published).
Newport Resort lists full kitchens in rooms (ovens, stovetops, full-size refrigerators). Open Hearth rooms include refrigerators and microwaves but do not publish full in-room kitchens.
No — both properties are listed as all-ages (family-friendly features are noted at Open Hearth Lodge).
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·