
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families, groups and travelers bringing dogs who want on-site activities and an indoor pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a family-friendly Sister Bay lodge with an indoor heated pool, playground and dedicated dog wing — read this if you want a roomy, activity-focused Door County stay for all ages. Chanticleer Cabins is a small Sturgeon Bay luxury B&B made up of private, wood-sided cabins for adults — read this if you want a quiet, romantic cabin escape with simple breakfast and outdoor privacy.
Updated

Best for families, groups and travelers bringing dogs who want on-site activities and an indoor pool.

Best for couples or adults seeking private, quiet cabins and a low-key, romantic stay.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: Choose Open Hearth if you need space for kids or groups, want an indoor heated pool open year-round, pet-friendly rooms in a designated wing, and lots of on-site activities and grounds.
When Chanticleer Cabins wins: Choose Chanticleer for a quieter, adults-only cabin experience, private patios/balconies, jetted tubs in each cabin option and a setting focused on privacy and outdoor time.
Bottom line: Open Hearth is the practical, activity-rich pick for families, dog owners and groups; Chanticleer is the smaller, more private adults-only option for couples and travelers who prioritize cabin seclusion.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | Chanticleer Cabins |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Family-oriented lodge with large grounds and activity spaces | Small, quiet, adults-only cabin B&B with private patios |
| Location (town) | Sister Bay (south end) | Sturgeon Bay (Cherry Rd) |
| Size | 55 rooms on ~6.4 acres | 4 individually decorated cabins |
| Ages | All ages welcome (family focus) | Adults-only (guests under 18 not permitted) |
| Pools | Year-round heated indoor pool + adjacent jacuzzi/whirlpool | No on-site pool listed (swimming nearby) |
| Restaurants & bars | No full-service on-site restaurant; free continental breakfast, BBQ grills and lobby vending | No full-service on-site restaurant noted; complimentary on-the-go breakfast |
| Wellness & spa | Fitness center and infrared sauna; no dedicated treatment spa on site | No on-site treatment spa listed; nearby spas referenced |
| Known for | Indoor pool, family amenities, dog-friendly wing and large grounds | Private cabins with jetted tubs, fireplaces and quiet, romantic packages |
| Parking & transport | Free self-parking; off-street motor-coach parking available | Free self parking and secured parking; no accessible shuttle |
| Breakfast | Free daily continental breakfast (conveyor pancake maker) | |
| Pet policy | Dog-friendly wing (14 rooms), fee per dog, cats not permitted | Not pet-friendly — adults-only policy forbids under-18 guests (supplier listing doesn’t list pets allowed) |
Open Hearth Lodge sits on roughly 6.4 acres at the south end of Sister Bay, on Highway 42.
Pick Open Hearth for easy access to Sister Bay’s family-friendly waterfront, trails and nearby dining.
Chanticleer Cabins is located at 4017 Cherry Rd in Sturgeon Bay, a short drive from Sunset Park Beach and local galleries.
Pick Chanticleer for a quieter Sturgeon Bay base close to beaches, galleries and a smaller-town pace.
Open Hearth Lodge offers 55 rooms with King or two-Queen layouts, suites and several rooms with whirlpool tubs or fireplaces.
Choose Open Hearth if you need flexible room types for families, suites or pet-friendly accommodations.
Chanticleer has four individually decorated cabins (Tamarack, Hemlock, Evergreen, Oak) each listed with a king bed and jetted tub.
Pick Chanticleer when you want a private cabin with a jetted tub, small-kitchen facilities and adult-oriented quiet.
Open Hearth doesn’t run a full-service restaurant; it provides a free continental breakfast and outdoor cooking facilities.
If you want self-catered meals, casual BBQs and a simple breakfast on-site, Open Hearth fits that bill.
Chanticleer provides a complimentary on-the-go breakfast and outdoor picnic/grill areas, but no full-service on-site restaurant.
Chanticleer is best for travelers who plan to dine out locally or prepare simple meals at their cabin.
Open Hearth’s signature amenity is its year-round heated indoor pool and adjacent whirlpool.
If an indoor pool that’s usable in any season matters to you, Open Hearth is the clearer choice.
Chanticleer does not list an on-site pool; the property emphasizes private outdoor spaces, a terrace and a garden.
Chanticleer suits guests who prefer cabin solitude and outdoor relaxation rather than a hotel pool area.
Open Hearth focuses on family- and activity-oriented on-site amenities rather than evening nightlife.
Pick Open Hearth for fitness facilities and family entertainment; it’s not a nightlife hub.
Chanticleer centers on quiet evenings at your cabin with garden/terrace seating and proposal/romance packages.
Chanticleer is aimed at couples who want low-key evenings and local dining or winery outings.

Open Hearth — large grounds, indoor pool, playground and varied room types for families and groups.

Chanticleer — four private cabins with jetted tubs, fireplaces and adults-only rules for quiet stays.

Open Hearth — dedicated 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area and dog wash.

Chanticleer — private patios, proposal/romance packages and a quiet property layout.
Open Hearth Lodge — it offers family-focused amenities like an indoor heated pool, playground and family-sized rooms.
The Chanticleer supplier listing specifies an adults-only policy (guests under 18 not permitted) and does not list pet-friendly rooms; check with the property directly, but do not assume pets are allowed.
No — neither property advertises a full-service on-site restaurant; both provide complimentary breakfast options and outdoor grills, with nearby dining available in town.
Open Hearth Lodge has a year-round heated indoor pool and adjacent whirlpool; Chanticleer does not list an on-site pool.
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·