
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families and dog owners who want a compact resort with a big lawn, pool, and trail access in Sister Bay.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a family-oriented Sister Bay lodge on 6.4 acres with an indoor heated pool, playground, and a 14-room dog wing — good for active families who want easy access to peninsula trails and Sister Bay. The Rushes is a townhouse-style, waterfront condo resort on Kangaroo Lake in Baileys Harbor with kitchens, an indoor pool and hot tub — best for families or groups who want lake access and self-catered condo space.
Updated · about 9 miles (≈14.5 km) apart

Best for families and dog owners who want a compact resort with a big lawn, pool, and trail access in Sister Bay.

Best for travelers who want condo-style space and direct access to Kangaroo Lake for paddling and lakeside downtime.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: Choose Open Hearth if you want a family-oriented property with a wide indoor pool, free continental breakfast, large grounds with a playground and fire pit, and easy access to Sister Bay attractions. It’s also the better pick if you’re bringing a dog and need a designated pet wing and dog wash.
When The Rushes wins: Pick The Rushes for townhouse/condo layouts with full kitchens and private balconies, direct proximity to Kangaroo Lake, and a broader range of on-site activities (arcade/game room, table tennis, tennis courts, canoe/kayak access) — useful for multi-night stays where you plan to self-cater and use on-site recreation.
Bottom line: For a classic, family-focused Sister Bay lodge experience with large grounds and an indoor pool, go with Open Hearth Lodge. For lakefront condo living, kitchens, and more on-site recreational options in Baileys Harbor, choose The Rushes.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | The Rushes |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Family-focused lodge with large shared grounds and activity spaces | Townhouse-style condo resort with waterfront units and many on-site activities |
| Location | South end of Sister Bay, on Hwy 42, near shops and Sister Bay Beach | 3014 Rushes Rd, Baileys Harbor, on Kangaroo Lake (lake nearby) |
| Size | 55 rooms on about 6.4 acres | 50 individually decorated guestrooms/condos |
| Ages | All ages; family- and kid-friendly | All ages; family-friendly |
| Pools & hot tubs | Year-round heated indoor pool + adjacent whirlpool (open 8:00 AM–10:00 PM) | Indoor pool and hot tub (one each) listed in supplier details |
| Restaurants & bars | No full-service restaurant; free continental breakfast + grills and vending | Not published |
| Wellness & fitness | Fitness center and infrared sauna on site; no dedicated spa treatments | Fitness facilities and sauna listed; spa treatments not published |
| Known for | Large family grounds, indoor pool, dog-friendly wing, easy Sister Bay access | Lakeside condos with private balconies and on-site recreational options |
| Self-catering | No in-room kitchens; shared grills and fire pit for cookouts | Rooms include kitchens (refrigerator, oven, stovetop) in condo units |
| Distance between properties | about 9 miles (≈14.5 km) | |
Open Hearth Lodge sits on the south end of Sister Bay on Hwy 42, close to Sister Bay Beach and local restaurants.
Choose Open Hearth to be close to Sister Bay’s shops, dining, and waterfront park.
The Rushes is located in Baileys Harbor on Kangaroo Lake, with lake access and easy drives to Lake Michigan shoreline parks.
Pick The Rushes if you want to be on Kangaroo Lake and closer to Baileys Harbor’s east-side attractions.
Open Hearth offers 55 rooms and suites across several room types, including dog-friendly rooms and whirlpool/ fireplace options.
Open Hearth is best if you want hotel-style rooms with some suite options and pet-designated rooms.
The Rushes supplies townhouse-style units (example: Signature Condo, 2 Bedrooms, Balcony, Lake View) with kitchens and private balconies.
The Rushes suits travelers who prefer condo space and cooking facilities during their stay.
Open Hearth does not run a full restaurant but includes a complimentary continental breakfast and cookout facilities.
Open Hearth is convenient for quick breakfasts and outdoor grilling but not for on-site dining service.
The Rushes units have kitchens for self-catering; front desk hours are limited and no full-service restaurant is published.
The Rushes is set up for self-catering and private meals in condo units; there’s no published full-service restaurant.
Open Hearth’s standout amenity is its year-round heated indoor pool and adjacent jacuzzi-style whirlpool.
If a sizable indoor pool and family pool hours matter, Open Hearth is a strong pick.
The Rushes combines an indoor pool and hot tub with direct access to Kangaroo Lake and many on-site recreation options.
Choose The Rushes for the blend of on-site recreation plus immediate lake access.
Open Hearth has a fitness center and an infrared sauna but no dedicated treatment spa.
Open Hearth covers basic wellness needs (gym, sauna) but not a full spa menu.
The Rushes lists fitness facilities and a sauna and offers nightlife-leaning indoor recreation spaces.
The Rushes provides casual on-site wellness and more evening recreation options than a typical hotel lobby.

Open Hearth — playground, large grounds, family-friendly pool hours, and kid-friendly breakfast.

The Rushes — townhouse/condo units with kitchens and direct access to Kangaroo Lake.

Open Hearth — a dedicated 14-room dog wing, dog wash, and a fenced dog area on property.

The Rushes — tennis courts, table tennis, miniature golf, arcade/game room, and water sports on site.
The Rushes — condo units include kitchens (refrigerator, oven, stovetop). Open Hearth has grills and a continental breakfast but no in-room kitchens.
Open Hearth accepts dogs but only in designated dog-friendly rooms (reserve in advance and expect a fee). The Rushes listing doesn’t publish a pet policy in the supplied details.
Open Hearth advertises a wide, year-round heated indoor pool described as 'made for cannonballs'; The Rushes lists one indoor pool but does not detail its size.
Open Hearth does not operate a full-service restaurant (offers free continental breakfast and grills). The Rushes has no named on-site restaurant published in the supplied listing.
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·