
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families with dogs and travelers who want outdoor grounds and on-site casual activities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a 55-room, family- and pet-friendly meadow-side lodge with active grounds and an indoor pool; read this if you want a casual, kid- and dog-friendly stay with on-site outdoor space. Scandinavian Lodge is a 47-room aparthotel of condo-style suites with resort recreation (indoor pool, tennis courts); read this if you prefer self-catered suites and on-site facilities like pools and fitness.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for families with dogs and travelers who want outdoor grounds and on-site casual activities.

Best for travelers who want condo-style space, an indoor pool plus outdoor tennis and built-in resort amenities.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: choose Open Hearth if you want a social, all-ages property with big meadow grounds, kid-focused amenities (playground, game room), a large year-round indoor pool, and dog-friendly rooms in a dedicated wing.
When Scandinavian Lodge wins: choose Scandinavian Lodge if you need condo-style layouts (Studio Suite up to 3-bedroom Condos), on-site resort facilities (indoor pool, outdoor seasonal pool, sauna, tennis court), and a location within easy walking distance of Waterfront Park and Sister Bay Beach.
Bottom line: pick Open Hearth Lodge for outdoor space, pet policies, and a family-lodgelike vibe; pick Scandinavian Lodge for apartment-style rooms and a compact resort experience with more built-in recreational facilities.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | Scandinavian Lodge |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Casual family lodge set on meadow grounds; activity-focused for kids and dogs. | Aparthotel / condo-style property with resort recreation and family focus. |
| Location (Sister Bay) | South end of Sister Bay on Highway 42, on ~6.4 acres. | 10506 State HWY 57 — within walking distance of Waterfront Park and Sister Bay Beach. |
| Size / rooms | 55 guest rooms, mix of standard rooms and suites, 14-room dog wing. | 47 air-conditioned rooms (Studio Suite, 1–3 Bedroom Condos). |
| Ages / policy | All ages; family- and kid-friendly (playground, game room). | Family-friendly (children’s pool listed); not adults-only. |
| Pools | Year-round heated indoor pool and adjacent jacuzzi/whirlpool (hours published). | Indoor pool plus outdoor seasonal pool (seasonal dates published). |
| Restaurants & bars | No full-service on-site restaurant; free continental breakfast, BBQ grills, fire pit, lobby vending. | Not published |
| Wellness & fitness | Fitness center and infrared sauna on site (hours published); whirlpool but no full-service spa. | Fitness facilities and sauna listed; no named on-site spa published. |
| Known for | Large grounds (6.4 acres), dog-friendly wing, family activities and event/group hosting. | Condo-style suites with private balconies/patios, indoor pool, tennis court, arcade/game room. |
| Accessibility & services | Free Wi‑Fi, free self-parking, inside room entries; front desk hours published. | Free WiFi, elevator, wheelchair-accessible features, limited front desk hours noted. |
| Nearby beach & park | Close to Sister Bay beaches and Waterfront Park (short drive or walk depending on room). | |
Open Hearth sits at the south end of Sister Bay on Highway 42 with large meadow grounds.
Choose Open Hearth for more outdoor space and immediate trail access.
Scandinavian Lodge is inside Sister Bay with easy walking access to the waterfront.
Choose Scandinavian Lodge for a more central Sister Bay location within walking distance of the waterfront.
Open Hearth offers traditional hotel rooms and suites with family- and pet-friendly options.
Pick Open Hearth for standard hotel rooms with family and dog-friendly configurations.
Scandinavian Lodge provides condo-style accommodations from Studio Suite to 3-Bedroom Condos.
Choose Scandinavian Lodge when you want apartment-style space for families or groups.
Open Hearth focuses on simple on-site meals and self-catering options rather than a staffed restaurant.
Bring or plan to visit local restaurants; cooking for a group is easy with grills and suites.
Scandinavian Lodge listing does not show a named on-site restaurant.
Dining is handled off-property or by self-catering in condo-style units.
Open Hearth centers a lot of guest activity on its grounds and indoor pool.
Open Hearth is strong on varied on-site recreation for families and groups.
Scandinavian Lodge has resort-style recreational amenities for guests staying in units.
Scandinavian offers more formal resort facilities like tennis and both indoor and outdoor pools.
Open Hearth provides basic wellness and evening social spaces rather than resort spa services.
Good for low-key relaxation and family evenings; book off-site treatments if you want professional spa services.
Scandinavian Lodge lists wellness amenities focused on fitness and a sauna.
Expect basic wellness features and on-property evening activities but no published full spa menu.

Open Hearth — dedicated 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area and dog wash; pet rooms by request.

Scandinavian Lodge — Studio Suite up to 3-Bedroom Condos with private balconies/patios.

Open Hearth — 6.4 acres with playground, disc golf, fire pit, BBQ grills, and trail access.

Scandinavian Lodge — indoor and outdoor pools, tennis court, arcade and on-site fitness.
Open Hearth Lodge — it has a dedicated 14-room dog wing, a dog exercise area and dog wash; pets must be reserved in advance and a fee applies.
Scandinavian Lodge is within about a 10–15 minute walk of Waterfront Park and Sister Bay Beach; Open Hearth is nearby but sits at the south end of town on larger grounds.
Neither property lists a full-service spa; Open Hearth has no on-site restaurant (continental breakfast, grills and vending only), and Scandinavian Lodge's listing does not publish a named on-site restaurant.
Open Hearth positions itself for groups and weddings with larger grounds and event coordination; Scandinavian offers larger condo units that may suit groups wanting private space but does not advertise event venues the way Open Hearth does.
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·