
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families, groups, or pet owners who want shared on-site amenities and on-property activities.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a family-friendly lodge in Sister Bay with shared on-site amenities (indoor heated pool, whirlpool, playground) for travelers who want activity and convenience. Loma Cottages in Fish Creek is a small cottage property for travelers who want independent, quieter stays with private cottage units and self-catering options.
Updated · about 10 miles apart

Best for families, groups, or pet owners who want shared on-site amenities and on-property activities.

Best for travelers who prefer a standalone cottage, more privacy, and a self-catered stay near Fish Creek and Lake Michigan.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: Choose Open Hearth Lodge if you want a single property with an indoor heated pool, whirlpool, fitness room, playground, and grounds for group activities — especially helpful for families or visitors bringing a dog.
When Loma Cottages wins: Choose Loma Cottages if you prefer an independent cottage layout, quieter privacy, and a simple self-parking base close to Fish Creek and Lake Michigan without shared-lodge traffic.
Bottom line: Open Hearth Lodge is the practical choice for active families or groups who value on-site amenities and programmed activity; Loma Cottages is the better match for travelers who prioritize standalone space and low-key privacy.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | Loma Cottages |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lively, family- and group-friendly lodge with many shared amenities and outdoor activity space. | Quiet, independent cottages offering privacy and self-catering options. |
| Location | Sister Bay on Highway 42 at the south end of town, close to Sister Bay Beach and local attractions. | Fish Creek (4291 County EE), within a short drive of The Orchards at Egg Harbor and Lake Michigan. |
| Distance between properties | about 10 miles to Fish Creek | |
| Size / scale | 55 guest rooms; 6.4 acres of grounds with patios, fire pit, playground and activity areas. | Multiple standalone cottages (listed room types: Andern, Alma, Shade Tree, Juniper, Applewood, Farmhouse). |
| Ages / audience | All ages — family-oriented and pet-friendly (designated dog wing and dog facilities). | All ages — not adults-only; cottage stays suit couples and families seeking privacy. |
| Pools & hot tubs | Year‑round heated indoor pool and adjacent jacuzzi whirlpool (open daily 8:00 AM–10:00 PM). | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | No full-service on-site restaurant; free daily continental breakfast, 24/7 vending, outdoor BBQ grills and fire pit for guest use. | No on-site full-service restaurant listed; cottages include self-catering facilities and free self parking. |
| Spa / wellness | Fitness center and infrared sauna on site; no dedicated full-service spa (on-site whirlpool noted). | Not published |
| Known for | Family activities, indoor pool, dog-friendly wing, grounds for group events and weddings. | Independent cottage stays with privacy and proximity to Fish Creek attractions and Lake Michigan. |
| Parking & access | Free self-parking plus off-street motor-coach/bus parking; no advertised shuttle service. | Free self-parking; property provides access codes and online registration (no front desk). |
Open Hearth Lodge sits at the south end of Sister Bay on Highway 42 with easy access to local beaches and town attractions.
Best if you want quick access to Sister Bay’s shoreline, restaurants, and family attractions.
Loma Cottages is in Fish Creek (4291 County EE), a short drive from Egg Harbor attractions and Lake Michigan.
Best if you want a base near Fish Creek attractions and easy access to Lake Michigan.
Open Hearth Lodge offers a range of rooms and suites (55 total) including pet-friendly rooms and suites with whirlpools or fireplaces.
Better for travelers who want varied room types and pet-friendly options within one property.
Loma Cottages rents standalone cottages (listed names include Andern, Alma, Shade Tree, Juniper, Applewood, Farmhouse).
Best if you prefer a private cottage with self-contained amenities rather than a shared-lodge layout.
Open Hearth Lodge does not operate a full-service restaurant but provides breakfast and guest-use cooking facilities.
Good for guests who plan to eat out locally or self-cook using the lodge’s grills.
Loma Cottages centers on self-catering cottage stays with free self-parking and access to nearby dining in Fish Creek.
A practical choice if you want private cooking space and local dining options nearby.
Open Hearth Lodge focuses on on-site activity spaces and an indoor pool for year-round use.
Ideal if you want reliable on-site recreation and an indoor pool regardless of season.
Loma Cottages emphasizes cottage privacy and outdoor quiet rather than large shared amenities.
Choose Loma Cottages for quieter outdoor space and cottage-style evenings rather than shared pool activities.
Open Hearth Lodge provides on-site wellness and low-key nighttime options for families and couples.
Good for guests who want basic wellness facilities and evening social spaces without a bar or nightclub.
Loma Cottages does not list a fitness center or a nightlife venue; evenings are typically quiet and cottage-focused.
Pick Loma Cottages for quiet evenings; go into town for spa services or nightlife.

Open Hearth Lodge — indoor heated pool, playground, family-oriented activities, and breakfast included.

Loma Cottages — standalone cottages and private entry for quieter stays and self-catering.

Open Hearth Lodge — dedicated dog wing, dog run, and dog wash make traveling with dogs easier.

Loma Cottages — cottage units with kitchen/washer-dryer facilities and BBQ access for independent stays.
Open Hearth Lodge — it has an indoor heated pool, playground, family activity areas, and a complimentary continental breakfast.
Loma Cottages — cottage units provide more privacy and fewer shared amenity crowds than a lodge.
Open Hearth Lodge allows dogs in a 14-room dedicated dog wing with a fee; Loma Cottages’ pet policy isn’t specified in the supplier listing and should be confirmed with the property.
No. Open Hearth Lodge includes a free continental breakfast; neither property advertises an all-inclusive meal plan.
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·