
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families, group stays, and guests who want on-site activities (pool, playground, BBQs).
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a family-friendly, group-oriented lodge on 6.4 acres at the south end of Sister Bay with year-round indoor pool and grounds for kids and dogs. Goose & Twigs is a smaller boutique lodging option in central Sister Bay with an on-site cafe vibe — good for travelers who want a walkable town base.
Updated · about 1.6 km apart

Best for families, group stays, and guests who want on-site activities (pool, playground, BBQs).

Best for travelers who want a small, walkable Sister Bay base with a cafe atmosphere and quick access to Waterfront Park.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: choose Open Hearth Lodge if you’re traveling with kids, a dog, or a larger group and want on-site recreation (indoor heated pool, whirlpool, playground, BBQs and big grounds).
When Goose & Twigs wins: pick Goose & Twigs if you want a compact, boutique stay within a few minutes’ walk of Waterfront Park, Sister Bay Beach, and the town’s restaurants and cafes.
Bottom line: Open Hearth Lodge is the practical pick for families and groups who plan to use hotel facilities; Goose & Twigs is better for travelers prioritizing a central, cafe-style boutique stay without the lodge’s activity-focused grounds.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | Goose & Twigs |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Lodge, family- and group-oriented with activity-focused grounds | Small boutique property with a cafe/snack-bar atmosphere |
| Location | South end of Sister Bay on Hwy 42, close to beaches and trails | Centrally located in Sister Bay, a short walk to Waterfront Park and Sister Bay Beach |
| Size | 55 rooms on ~6.4 acres; room types include suites and dog-friendly wing | 9 guestrooms (supplier listing) |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; family- and dog-friendly (14-room dog wing) | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Year-round heated indoor pool and adjacent jacuzzi whirlpool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | No full-service on-site restaurant; free continental breakfast, BBQ grills, vending/snacks | On-site coffee shop / cafe and snack bar/deli; complimentary daily reception |
| Spa / wellness | Fitness center and infrared sauna on site; no dedicated treatment spa | Not published |
| Known for | Large grounds with family amenities (playground, disc golf, fire pit), indoor pool, group-friendly event space | Central walkable location and a cafe atmosphere within blocks of the waterfront |
| Parking | Free self-parking plus coach/bus parking | |
| Accessibility | Standard accessibility features noted (inside entries, ground-level public areas) | Wheelchair accessible path of travel and some accessible features (may have limitations) |
Open Hearth Lodge sits at the south end of Sister Bay on Highway 42, on roughly 6.4 acres.
Good if you want space, trails and quick highway access while still being minutes from town.
Goose & Twigs is centrally located at 2322 Mill Rd, within a few minutes’ walk of Waterfront Park and Sister Bay Beach.
Best for travelers who want to be steps from the waterfront and town amenities.
Open Hearth Lodge has larger inventory and multiple room configurations for families and groups.
Choose Open Hearth for more room variety and family- or pet-friendly options.
Goose & Twigs lists 9 guestrooms with standard boutique-style layouts.
Goose & Twigs works for travelers who want a compact, tidy room in a central location.
Open Hearth Lodge does not operate a full-service restaurant but offers simple on-site meal options.
Plan to eat in town for full-service dining; the lodge covers basic breakfast and casual cookouts.
Goose & Twigs has a coffee shop / cafe on site and a snack bar/deli.
Goose & Twigs is convenient for light meals, coffee, and quick walks to town restaurants.
Open Hearth Lodge highlights a year-round heated indoor pool and an adjoining jacuzzi whirlpool.
The indoor pool is a core amenity for families and guests who want guaranteed swimming regardless of season.
Pool information for Goose & Twigs is not published in the supplier listing.
Not published — verify with Goose & Twigs if a pool is a deal-breaker.
Open Hearth Lodge provides basic wellness facilities on site and family-friendly evening options on the grounds.
Good on-site wellness basics; nightlife options are informal and centered on lodge gatherings or walking into town.
Goose & Twigs does not publish a dedicated wellness program or nightlife venue in the supplier listing.
Expect town nightlife nearby; the property itself focuses on lodging and a cafe-style food offering.

Open Hearth Lodge — on-site indoor pool, playground, large grounds and event/group support.

Goose & Twigs — central location within a few minutes’ walk of Waterfront Park and Sister Bay Beach.

Open Hearth Lodge — dedicated 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area and dog wash.

Goose & Twigs — on-site coffee shop/cafe and a snack bar/deli with daily complimentary reception.
Open Hearth Lodge — it has an indoor heated pool, playground, family-sized rooms and grounds designed for children.
Goose & Twigs — the supplier listing places it about 0.2 miles (0.3 km) from Waterfront Park and Sister Bay Beach.
No. Open Hearth includes a free continental breakfast; Goose & Twigs lists a cafe and daily reception but neither property is an all-inclusive.
Open Hearth Lodge has a dedicated dog-friendly wing and on-site pet amenities. Goose & Twigs’ supplier listing does not list a pet policy — confirm with the property if traveling with a pet.
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·