
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families and groups who want on-site activities (indoor pool, playground, BBQ/fire pit) and larger grounds.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a full‑amenity, family-oriented lodge in Sister Bay with a year‑round indoor pool and 6.4 acres of grounds; this guide is for families and active travelers who want on-site facilities. Fresh Coast Motel is a small, refreshed 2‑star motel in Fish Creek that works for no‑fuss Door County stays near the public beach; this guide is for travelers who prioritize location and simple, updated rooms.
Updated · about 10 miles (≈16 km) apart

Best for families and groups who want on-site activities (indoor pool, playground, BBQ/fire pit) and larger grounds.

Best for travelers who want a compact, recently refreshed motel near Fish Creek beach and Peninsula State Park access.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: Choose Open Hearth if you want an on-site heated indoor pool and whirlpool, fitness center and sauna, large outdoor grounds with family facilities, and a wider range of room types — it’s the easier pick for families, pet owners (designated dog wing), and groups.
When Fresh Coast Motel wins: Choose Fresh Coast Motel if you want a straightforward, clean motel footprint right in Fish Creek within walking distance of the public beach, Peninsula State Park trailheads, and local restaurants — good for short stays and beach-focused plans.
Bottom line: Pick Open Hearth Lodge for amenities and family-friendly programming; pick Fresh Coast Motel for location near Fish Creek’s beach and a simple, updated motel room experience.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | Fresh Coast Motel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Family-focused lodge with activity areas, casual barbecue/fire‑pit setup | Low‑key, refreshed motel in Fish Creek’s business district |
| Location | South end of Sister Bay on Highway 42 (Sister Bay beaches and town nearby) | 4125 Main St, Fish Creek — steps from Fish Creek Public Beach and close to Peninsula State Park |
| Size / rooms | 55 rooms, multiple suites and specialty options (dog wing, whirlpool rooms) | 15 air‑conditioned rooms; room list includes Standard and Premium options (see supplier room types) |
| Who it's for (ages) | All ages — family and pet friendly (dog wing, playground) | All ages — not adults‑only; some pet rooms available (fee applies) |
| Pools & water features | Year‑round heated indoor pool + adjacent jacuzzi whirlpool (open daily 8:00–22:00) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | No full‑service on‑site restaurant; free continental breakfast, vending, BBQ grills and cookout options | No on‑site restaurant listed; breakfast/meal options not published (nearby Fish Creek restaurants) |
| Spa & wellness | Fitness center and infrared sauna on site; no dedicated treatment spa (nearby off‑site spas recommended) | Health/beauty spa nearby (not an on‑site treatment spa) |
| Known for | Indoor pool made for family play, large grounds with activities and group/event hosting | Simple, refreshed motel lodging within walking distance of Fish Creek Public Beach |
| Pets | Designated 14‑room dog wing; $15/dog/night; cats not permitted | Pets allowed in specific rooms only; pet fee USD 85.13 per pet, per stay (service animals exempt) |
| Parking & connectivity | Free self‑parking, motor‑coach/bus parking; free WiFi | |
| Beach proximity | Close to Sister Bay Beach/Waterfront Park (Sister Bay side of the peninsula) | Steps from Fish Creek Public Beach; walkable to Sunset Beach Park and Peninsula State Park (~0.4 mi / 0.7 km) |
Open Hearth Lodge sits on the south end of Sister Bay on Highway 42, on roughly 6.4 acres.
Choose Open Hearth for a base near Sister Bay with big grounds and easy highway access.
Fresh Coast Motel is located on Main Street in Fish Creek, steps from Fish Creek Public Beach and close to Peninsula State Park.
Choose Fresh Coast Motel if you want walkable access to Fish Creek’s beach and park trails.
Open Hearth Lodge offers multiple room types across 55 rooms, including suites and specialty options.
Open Hearth is better when you want flexible room choices for families or groups.
Fresh Coast Motel has 15 air‑conditioned rooms in Standard and Premium layouts; some offer lake views or balconies.
Fresh Coast is straightforward and updated, with a few rooms that have lake views or balconies.
Open Hearth Lodge does not operate a full‑service restaurant but provides a free continental breakfast and outdoor cookout options.
Expect light on‑site food options and nearby independent restaurants for full meals.
Fresh Coast Motel listing does not show a full on‑site restaurant; nearby Fish Creek dining is the practical choice.
Plan to eat at nearby Fish Creek restaurants; the motel is focused on lodging rather than dining.
Open Hearth Lodge centers much of its guest experience on the indoor heated pool and large outdoor grounds.
Open Hearth is the pick if you plan to use on‑site recreation and pool facilities.
Fresh Coast Motel emphasizes a simple, refreshed stay with outdoor public beach access nearby.
Fresh Coast is focused on beach access and short walks to park trails rather than on‑site pools.
Open Hearth provides basic wellness facilities and relaxed evening options on the grounds.
Open Hearth blends fitness and casual evening activities on site; treatment spas are off‑property.
Fresh Coast Motel does not list a treatment spa but notes a health/beauty spa nearby.
For spa treatments or a gym, plan to visit off‑property providers in Fish Creek or nearby towns.

Open Hearth Lodge — indoor pool, playground, large grounds, and many room types including suites and pet wing.

Open Hearth Lodge — fitness center, infrared sauna, heated indoor pool with adjacent whirlpool, and outdoor activity areas.

Fresh Coast Motel — steps from Fish Creek Public Beach and an easy walk to Peninsula State Park access.

Fresh Coast Motel — refreshed motel rooms, free WiFi, free self parking and a Fish Creek business‑district address.
Open Hearth Lodge — it has a heated indoor pool, playground, large grounds and family‑oriented facilities.
Fresh Coast Motel — the supplier listing shows Peninsula State Park about 0.4 miles (0.7 km) away from the motel.
Yes. Open Hearth has a 14‑room dog wing ($15/dog/night). Fresh Coast allows pets in specific rooms for a pet fee (USD 85.13 per pet, per stay); service animals are exempt.
Neither property operates a full‑service on‑site restaurant; Open Hearth offers a free continental breakfast and BBQ grills, while Fresh Coast lists a health/beauty spa nearby (no on‑site treatment spa published).
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·