
Open Hearth Lodge
Best for families, dogs, and travelers wanting on-site recreation (pool, playground, fire pit) in Door County.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Open Hearth Lodge is a family-friendly Door County lodge with extensive grounds, an indoor heated pool, and pet-friendly rooms — good for families and active travelers who want space and on-site activities. Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay is a budget, beachfront chain motel in Menominee, Michigan, aimed at value-minded travelers who want simple rooms and quick access to Lake Michigan.
Updated

Best for families, dogs, and travelers wanting on-site recreation (pool, playground, fire pit) in Door County.

Best for budget-focused travelers who want a simple, beachfront stay with free breakfast and basic fitness/sauna facilities.
When Open Hearth Lodge wins: Choose Open Hearth Lodge if you want space for kids and pets, an indoor heated pool and whirlpool open year-round, and acres of grounds with BBQs, playground, and outdoor activities in Sister Bay.
When Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay wins: Choose Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay if you need an affordable, no-frills motel steps from Lake Michigan with free self-serve breakfast, free parking, and straightforward chain-standard rooms.
Bottom line: Open Hearth Lodge is the better option for families and people who value on-site amenities and grounds; Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay is the sensible pick for waterfront, budget-conscious stays with basic fitness/sauna options and easy access to Menominee town sights.
| Category | Open Hearth Lodge | Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Family-focused Door County lodge with outdoor grounds and group-friendly spaces | Simple, value beachfront motel in Menominee with chain-standard rooms |
| Location | South end of Sister Bay, WI (on Highway 42) with direct access to trails and local beaches | Centrally located in Menominee, steps from Lake Michigan waterfront |
| Size (rooms) | 55 guest rooms | 49 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages; family- and dog-friendly (dog wing, playground) | All ages; not adults-only |
| Indoor pool / water features | Year-round heated indoor pool plus adjacent jacuzzi whirlpool (hours published) | Sauna and fitness center listed; no guest pool published |
| Restaurants & bars | No full-service on-site restaurant; free daily continental breakfast, BBQ grills, fire pit, and lobby vending | Free self-serve breakfast, coffee/tea in common area, vending machine; limited on-site food service |
| Wellness / fitness | On-site fitness center and an infrared sauna (hours published) | Fitness facilities and sauna listed |
| Pet policy | Designated 14-room dog-friendly wing; $15 per dog/night; up to two dogs/room; cats not permitted | Some rooms are pet friendly (Pet fee: USD 20 per pet, per night; service animals exempt) |
| Parking & access | Free self-parking plus motor-coach/bus parking | Free self parking and RV/bus/truck parking |
| Notable extras | 6.4 acres with playground, disc golf, indoor game room, bowling alley and mini golf (property features listed) | Steps from Lake Michigan; Near Three Bridge Brewing Company and Menominee attractions |
Open Hearth Lodge sits on roughly 6.4 acres at the south end of Sister Bay on Highway 42, close to local beaches, parks, and Door County day-trip options.
Best if you want a Door County base with direct access to outdoor activities and local attractions.
Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay is centrally located in Menominee with very short walks to the Lake Michigan shoreline and local points of interest.
Best if you want a basic waterfront location within walking distance of Menominee’s small-town sights.
Open Hearth Lodge offers 55 rooms in many configurations, including suites, King Whirlpool rooms and a dedicated dog wing.
Better variety and family/pet-friendly room options for multi-person stays.
Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay has 49 guestrooms with standard chain amenities aimed at value travelers.
Solid, straightforward rooms for budget travel; fewer specialty suites than a small independent lodge.
Open Hearth Lodge does not operate a full-service restaurant; dining is casual and guest-focused.
Plan to eat off-property for full-service dining; on-site options are basic and family-friendly.
Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay provides basic on-site breakfast and limited food/beverage amenities.
Good for a quick grab-and-go breakfast; expect to eat in town for full dining choices.
Open Hearth Lodge’s standout amenity is its family-oriented recreation: a year-round indoor heated pool plus grounds activity areas.
Choose Open Hearth if on-site recreation and an indoor pool are priorities.
Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay’s key appeal is immediate access to Lake Michigan rather than a hotel pool.
Pick Econo Lodge for beach access and a basic fitness/sauna setup rather than an on-site swimming pool.
Open Hearth Lodge supports active stays with a fitness center and infrared sauna plus evening family activities on the grounds.
Good choice for active travelers who want on-property fitness and quiet evening communal spaces.
Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay lists fitness facilities and a sauna as on-site amenities and is within walking distance of Menominee bars and breweries.
Works for travelers wanting a basic fitness/sauna offering and quick access to local restaurants and breweries.

Open Hearth Lodge — indoor heated pool, playground, game room and expansive grounds make it a clear family pick.

Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay — low-cost rooms literally steps from Lake Michigan for travelers prioritizing the beach on a budget.

Open Hearth Lodge — dedicated 14-room dog wing, dog exercise area and wash, and pet-friendly grounds.

Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay — chain-level basics, complimentary breakfast, and value pricing aimed at budget stays.
Open Hearth Lodge — it has an indoor heated pool, playground, family activities, and larger grounds suited to kids.
Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay — the supplier listing places the property about 0.1 km from Lake Michigan (steps to the waterfront).
Yes. Open Hearth has a 14-room dog-friendly wing with a $15 per dog fee and rules; Econo Lodge Menomonie On The Bay allows pets in specific rooms for USD 20 per pet per night (service animals exempt).
No. Neither property operates a full-service, named restaurant on site; both offer breakfast and limited on-site food/beverage options and have nearby dining in town.
Explore how Open Hearth Lodge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·