Bringing a dog? How Open Hearth Lodge's pet policy actually works

Yes — Open Hearth Lodge allows dogs but only in designated dog-friendly rooms (a 14-room dog wing). You must reserve a pet room in advance; there’s an additional $15 per dog per night fee, up to two dogs per room, and service animals are exempt from the fee.
In this guide
Which rooms accept dogs
Open Hearth Lodge keeps pets confined to a dedicated dog-friendly wing. The property specifically lists dog rooms such as Lodge (Dog Friendly), Standard Room (Dog Friendly), Premium (Dog Friendly) Room, and Premier 1 Bedroom Suite (Dog Friendly).
Dog rooms must be requested and reserved in advance — you cannot assume a regular room will accept pets.
- Dog-friendly room types (examples from the property): Lodge (Dog Friendly); Standard Room (Dog Friendly); Premium (Dog Friendly) Room; Premier 1 Bedroom Suite (Dog Friendly).
- Other room types listed as No Pets (for example Lodge (No Pets), Deluxe (No Pets) Room, Deluxe Apartment (No Pets)) do not accept dogs.
| Room name (examples) | Pet status |
|---|---|
| Standard Room (Dog Friendly) | Dog rooms — must reserve in advance |
| Premium (Dog Friendly) Room | Dog rooms — must reserve in advance |
| Deluxe (No Pets) Room | No pets allowed |

Fees, limits, and rules
Open Hearth Lodge charges an additional $15 per dog per night for dogs in designated pet rooms. The property allows up to two dogs per room. Service animals are exempt from the pet fee.
There are behavioral and housekeeping rules: dogs must be crated if left unattended in the room. Cats are not permitted at the property.
- $15 per dog per night (fee applies to pets; service animals exempt)
- Maximum two dogs per room
- Dogs must be crated if left alone in the room
- Cats are not allowed
| Policy item | What the property requires |
|---|---|
| Reservation | Must reserve a dog-friendly room in advance |
| Fee | $15 per dog, per night (service animals exempt) |
| Unattended dogs | Must be crated if left alone |
On-site pet amenities and where dogs can go
Open Hearth Lodge provides pet-focused features on the grounds: a dog exercise area and a dog wash are listed among property amenities. Dogs can be walked anywhere on the property.
The lodge’s 6.4-acre grounds include grassy areas, trails, and outdoor gathering spaces (patio, fire pit, BBQ grills) that guests commonly use while walking dogs. Always follow leash and local rules when off your room area.
- Dog exercise area (fenced area noted in property materials)
- Dog wash available on site
- Dogs may be walked anywhere on the property
| Amenity | Notes |
|---|---|
| Dog exercise area | On-site fenced area for dogs |
| Dog wash | Available on property for rinsing/cleaning pets |
| Grounds access | Dogs may be walked across the 6.4-acre property |

Before arrival: reservations, check-in, and payment
If you plan to bring a dog, explicitly request a dog-friendly room when you book and confirm the pet room reservation with the property. The lodge’s pet rooms are a limited, dedicated wing and must be reserved in advance.
At check-in you’ll need a government-issued photo ID and a credit/debit card or cash deposit for incidentals. The front desk is staffed daily from 7:30 AM to 10:00 PM; if you arrive after 10:00 PM contact the property in advance for check-in instructions.
- Reserve a dog-friendly room in advance — availability is limited to the dog wing
- Bring photo ID and a credit card or cash deposit at check-in
- Front desk hours: 7:30 AM–10:00 PM (guests arriving after 10:00 PM must arrange ahead)
| Check-in detail | What to expect |
|---|---|
| ID & payment | Photo ID + card or cash deposit required |
| Front desk hours | 7:30 AM–10:00 PM; arrange late arrival in advance |
| Check-in time | Starts at 3:30 PM |

Staying with your dog: in-room and public-area guidance
Rooms include in-room refrigerators and microwaves; some dog-friendly room types include a sofa bed or extra space (for example Premier 1 Bedroom Suite (Dog Friendly) or Premium (Dog Friendly) Room). Keep pets on furniture policies in mind — the property’s specific in-room rules should be confirmed at check-in.
While dogs are allowed on the grounds and in dog rooms, do not assume pets are allowed in every indoor public space — always check with staff about specific public-area restrictions and clean-up expectations.
- Confirm in-room pet rules (e.g., furniture access, extra cleaning requirements) at check-in
- Crate dogs if you need to leave them unattended
- Pick up after pets and follow property clean-up rules
| Tip | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Bring your own crate | Required if leaving your dog unattended; also helps protect bedding |
| Pack cleaning supplies | You’ll be responsible for messes beyond normal wear |
| Keep ID and vaccination records handy | Staff may request proof in some circumstances |
Nearby dog-friendly activities and practical notes
Open Hearth Lodge sits at the south end of Sister Bay on Highway 42, a short drive from waterfront parks and beaches. Sister Bay Beach / Waterfront Park and nearby walking/biking trails are popular outdoor areas where well-behaved, leashed dogs can join owners; confirm local beach regulations before you go.
You’ll need a car to explore Door County reliably — there’s no practical public transit. Nearby attractions listed by the lodge include Frykman Studio Gallery and Pirate’s Cove Adventure Golf within walking distance, and many outdoor day-trip options (Peninsula State Park, Washington Island ferry) a short drive away.
- Sister Bay Beach / Waterfront Park — sandy beach and park within town (check leash rules)
- Peninsula State Park (about 5 miles south) — trails, bike routes; bring a leash and water
- Washington Island ferry (north) — day-trip option (confirm ferry pet policies separately)
| Activity | Dog practicality |
|---|---|
| Sister Bay Beach / Waterfront Park | Check local rules; beaches sometimes have seasonal leash rules |
| Peninsula State Park | Trails and paved bike paths — dogs typically allowed on leash |
| Nearby town walks | Paved sidewalks and shops nearby; respect store policies on pets |


