Is Open Hearth Lodge worth staying at? Honest pros and cons

Yes — Open Hearth Lodge is a solid value for travelers who want a casual, family-friendly base in Sister Bay with year-round indoor pool/whirlpool, large grounds, and a mix of standard rooms and suites (including dog-friendly options). It’s not a full-service resort: don’t expect an on-site restaurant or spa treatments, but you will get free continental breakfast, BBQ grills, fitness/sauna facilities, and easy access to local beaches and trails.
In this guide
Location & setting
Open Hearth Lodge sits at 2669 South Bayshore Drive on the south end of Sister Bay, on roughly 6.4 acres of meadow and lawn. The property fronts Highway 42 and places you a short drive or walk from downtown Sister Bay attractions.
Because the lodge is on the south edge of town, it’s convenient for quick access to local beaches, parks, and nearby businesses named on the property site, and it provides on-site access to walking, biking, and seasonal snowmobile trails.
- Address: 2669 South Bayshore Drive, Sister Bay, WI 54234
- Property size: about 6.4 acres
- Close to Sister Bay Beach/Waterfront Park and multiple local shops and eateries (off-property)
| Nearby highlights | Typical distance (per hotel site) |
|---|---|
| Frykman Studio Gallery and Pirate's Cove Adventure Golf | About a 10-minute walk |
| Door County Creamery, Rigoniworks Art Gallery, Jischke's Meat Market | About a 5-minute drive |
| Peninsula State Park (day trip) | About 5 miles / roughly 15 minutes |

Rooms and suite options
The lodge has 55 guest rooms overall with a mix of standard rooms, suites, and specialty layouts. Room types listed by the property include Lodge (No Pets), Deluxe Room, Jetted Tub (No Pets), Premium Room (No Pets), Deluxe Apartment (No Pets), Evergreen 2 Bedroom Suite (No Pets), and several dog-friendly options such as Lodge (Dog Friendly) and Standard Room (Dog Friendly).
All rooms include basic in-room amenities the property lists: refrigerator, microwave, hairdryer, cable TV, air conditioning, and inside entries. Some rooms are noted as having working fireplaces or a jacuzzi/whirlpool tub—select room names explicitly referenced by the property include King Whirlpool rooms and the Deluxe Room, Jetted Tub (No Pets).
- Room names exactly as listed: Lodge (No Pets), Lodge (No Pet), Deluxe Room, Jetted Tub (No Pets), Premium Room (No Pets), Lodge (Dog Friendly), Standard Room (Dog Friendly), Deluxe (No Pets) Room, Deluxe Apartment (No Pets), Evergreen 2 Bedroom Suite (No Pets), Premium (Dog Friendly) Room, Premium Room, with Sofa bed, Jetted Tub, Premier 1 Bedroom Suite (Dog Friendly), Deluxe Room, Multiple Beds.
- Some suites provide living/kitchenette spaces (e.g., Deluxe Apartment, Evergreen 2 Bedroom Suite).
- If you need a pet room, you must reserve a dog-friendly room in advance.
| Typical amenity | Availability (per hotel info) |
|---|---|
| Refrigerator & microwave | Standard in all rooms |
| Free Wi‑Fi | Available in rooms and public areas |
| Select rooms with jetted tubs or fireplace | Available in some listed room types (see Deluxe Room, Jetted Tub (No Pets) and King Whirlpool references) |

On-site amenities — pool, fitness, and grounds
Open Hearth Lodge highlights a year-round heated indoor pool with a wide design the property describes as 'made for cannonballs' plus an adjacent jacuzzi/whirlpool that overlook the patio and yard. The pool and whirlpool hours are posted as 8:00 AM to 10:00 PM daily.
The property also has an on-site fitness center and an infrared sauna; those facilities are listed as open from 7:00 AM to 9:00 PM. The 6.4-acre grounds include a natural stone patio, gas grills, fire pit, playground, disc golf and bag toss, and direct trail access for walking, biking, and seasonal snowmobile use.
- Indoor pool & whirlpool: open daily 8:00 AM–10:00 PM (per property)
- Fitness center and infrared sauna: open daily 7:00 AM–9:00 PM
- Outdoor features: gas grills, stone patio/fire pit, playground, disc golf, trails
| Amenity | Hours listed by hotel |
|---|---|
| Indoor pool & whirlpool | 8:00 AM–10:00 PM |
| Fitness center & infrared sauna | 7:00 AM–9:00 PM |
| Front desk (staffed) | 7:30 AM–10:00 PM |

Family and pet policy — who can stay here
The property markets itself as family-friendly and lists on-site facilities for children such as a playground and pool; it also highlights family-friendly grounds and activities like disc golf and bag toss.
Open Hearth Lodge operates a designated 14-room dog-friendly wing. Dogs must be reserved in advance, are limited to two dogs per room, and there’s a pet fee listed on the property site (the site gives $15 per dog per night). Service animals are exempt from pet fees. The property also offers a fenced dog exercise area and a dog wash.
- Family-friendly amenities: playground, pool, game options on property
- Pet policy: dogs allowed only in designated dog-friendly rooms; reserve in advance; fee applies; cats not permitted
- Service animals: exempt from pet fees
| Item | Policy / note |
|---|---|
| Dog-friendly wing | 14 rooms; must reserve in advance |
| Dog fee | $15 per dog per night (per property info) |
| Maximum dogs per room | Up to 2 dogs |
Dining, food options, and nearby restaurants
Open Hearth Lodge does not operate a full-service, staff‑run restaurant or bar. The property provides a free daily continental breakfast (coffee, pastries, cereal, and a conveyor pancake maker) and 24/7 lobby vending for snacks and drinks, plus outdoor BBQ grills and a fire pit for guest cookouts.
For sit-down meals, guests typically visit nearby Sister Bay restaurants and cafes; the property lists several nearby businesses and points of interest but does not include a named on-site dining venue.
- On-site: free continental breakfast each morning, coffee and pastries, conveyor pancake maker
- No on-site full-service restaurant; guests should plan for off-property dining or use the BBQ grills
- Nearby dining options are in Sister Bay (not part of the hotel)
| Meal | Availability on site |
|---|---|
| Breakfast | Free continental breakfast provided |
| Lunch / dinner | No restaurant — grill/outdoor cookout or local restaurants |
| Snacks & beverages | Lobby vending machines available 24/7 |
Practical tips, who should pick this place, and when to go
If you want a straightforward, activity-oriented stay (pool, family facilities, large grounds, dog-friendly options) and plan to eat off-property or cook on the grills, Open Hearth Lodge fits well. Don’t pick it if you need an on-site full restaurant, a dedicated spa with treatments, or a boutique luxury experience.
Peak season in Door County is summer (warmer weather, more services open). September often balances milder weather and smaller crowds. Winters are quiet and useful for snow activities, but some local businesses may be closed outside summer season.
- Check-in begins at 3:30 PM; front desk staffed 7:30 AM–10:00 PM (arrivals after 10 PM must be arranged ahead)
- Standard check-out is 11:00 AM; late check-out may be available for a fee
- Bring a car — public transit is not practical on the peninsula
| Good for | Not ideal for |
|---|---|
| Families, pet owners who reserve in advance, groups wanting outdoor space | Travelers seeking on-site fine dining or a full-service spa |
| Visitors wanting pool, fitness, sauna and basic kitchen facilities in suites | Guests who need guaranteed late-night front desk service without prior arrangement (arrive after 10 PM only with notice) |
| People basing day trips around Peninsula State Park or Washington Island | Visitors reliant on public transportation |


